FamilyEducation Blogs


June 25, 2008

Nothing real about this show

I’m the first to admit that I watch too much TV. After long days of work and nights of parenting, I find it easy to melt in front of the boob tube and unwind. I’m not suggesting this is a good thing, by the way. If we were to homeschool K-Man, there’s a good chance he’d be more likely to recite the Survivor winners than the presidents, and he’d probably know the ramble of a Top Chef contestant before he'd know the Preamble to the U.S. Constitution. Tonight, however, NBC is airing a show that may very well get me off of TV forever (or at least for the summer): The Baby Borrowers.

Here’s the premise: Teenage couples will be given real, human babies, toddlers, preteens and tweeners to take care of (getting a new kid every three days). They will have to complete the daily chores that come with parenting. The purpose of the program is to illustrate how difficult it is to have a kid and be a parent. The show's tagline is "It’s not TV. It’s birth control." The official show website proclaims, "Learn more about this riveting social experiment where five teenage couples fast-track to parenthood."

Riveting social experiment? Fast-track to parenthood? Let’s not take ourselves quite so seriously. This is a TV show designed to generate ratings during the summer hiatus. This is an attempt to make money. This is nothing more than entertainment (and barely that, most likely).

I’m guessing that the five teenage couples will struggle mightily with parenting. And they should. They’re teenagers. They shouldn’t be on this show. They should be out drinking with their friends, shoplifting and having unprotected sex. Oh, wait. That’s not right, either. I shouldn’t make light of this, I guess. I’m just not sure what’s so funny about giving kids who are completely unequipped to deal with their own lives the responsibility of dealing with another life…for entertainment purposes.

I know, I know…Teenagers are having kids all the time. Maybe this will be a good program that does actually deter a teenager from wanting to have a kid. I kind of doubt it, though. You see, in order for the show to be a deterrent, the teens actually have to watch the program. I’m guessing the demographics of viewers won’t include too many teenagers. (Maybe those girls in MA who supposedly had a pregnancy pact should all watch it together. That’s a whole ‘nother blog posting.)

You want to give kids "real life experience" about what it’s like to have a kid? Don’t make it into a TV show for three weeks and try to pass it off as a "social experiment." Instead, have REAL teenage parents come talk to their peers about how much is sucks to be a teen…and a parent. Don’t create "reality TV," which will be edited to be kind of fun and funny. Instead, produce the kind of documentary that scares kids straight.

When I took my driver’s education course 100 years ago, we had to watch Red Asphalt. In that movie, a dude got his face ripped off. Granted, it doesn’t work for everyone, but it certainly worked for me. Show the kids in health class REAL movies about parenting. Show them a movie called "Sleep Deprivation," and follow it up with, "Empty Bank Account," and "Never See Your Friends." That might help keep some pants up.

I confess: I have the TiVo set to record this debacle of a show. I’m going to watch the first episode – with the same morbid curiosity that causes me to slow down and look at car accidents. But, just as I do with those accidents, I may not really look and I’ll probably just speed away.

K-Man won’t be watching this show with me.

Um, seems like you've totally missed the glaring irresponsibility associated with this show- the fact that they are exploiting the children. I never would have turned my children over at that young of an age (or any age- but especially as babies or toddlers) to teenagers without experience for entertainment. I'd have to be beyond bored with my life to watch this program.


302 people found this comment helpful

It's a strong point. I didn't so much overlook it, as (and this is even worse) I think I've just become too jaded to point it out. Seems there's so much of that on TV that I'm accustomed to it. The producers try to explain this away with, "all the while under 24-hour supervision by nannies and the real parents who are stationed next door, watching via monitor, and able to step in at any time." Uh huh...that makes it okay. It's just all too scary.


302 people found this comment helpful

The show seems safe, there is no way they would ever let anything bad happen to one of the children.


300 people found this comment helpful

I don't dissagree that it's a safety issue- I think it's a psychological issue for the child. It can't be good, mentally, for an infant or toddler to be placed in that situation. They may be scared or worse, develop seperation anxiety or have abandonment issues later on in life. We all know our problems as adults stem from our childhood.


301 people found this comment helpful

Amen. Apparently, my TiVo is smarter than I am. I set it to record the show, but it didn't make the channel change to do it. Even the machine didn't want to be associated with that cr*p! I'll take that as a fairly good sign that I shouldn't bother watching any of it.


302 people found this comment helpful